Skip to main content

Looking for some true crime present inspiration? We’ve got you covered. Check out the top 11 gifts for true crime lovers below.

There’s something for every true crime fan in your life!

This includes books, board games, card games, content subscriptions, jewelry, accessories, and makeup.

We’ve also included a handy link under each one of these true crime gifts so you can get the best price possible.

BLOODY ALPHABET - The Scariest Serial Killers Coloring Book

1. BLOODY ALPHABET – The Scariest Serial Killers Coloring Book

From $5.99 USD

  • Rating: 4.7 out of 5
  • Reviews: 13,595
  • Category: Coloring Book
  • Author: Brian Berry
  • Pages: 52

This adult coloring book would make the perfect gift for the true crime fan in your life.

It features 23 different killers, each one as notorious as the last. Ted Bundy, Charles Manson, Ricardo Ramirez, and The Zodiac Killer are all included.

Aside from the true crime theme, it’s a well-made coloring book in its own right.

The illustrations are detailed and high resolution, the pages are easy to tear out, and it’s done in single-sided pages so that you can display each piece of artwork and avoid the color bleeding through at the same time.

This is honestly one of the best gifts for serial killer fans, and the concept is so unique.

Combining something relaxing like coloring with a spine-chilling topic like true crime will leave you with a truly interesting experience.

Buy Now

Death At The Dive Bar - Immersive Murder Mystery Game

2. Death At The Dive Bar – Immersive Murder Mystery Game

From $31.99 USD

  • Rating: 4.7 out of 5
  • Reviews: 8,508
  • Category: Board Game
  • Brand: Hunt A Killer
  • Players: 1+

Hunt A Killer is a popular board game brand that makes immersive mystery-solving experiences for anyone that’s interested in true crime or just some good old-fashioned sleuthing.

It’s one of those gifts for murder mystery lovers that’s guaranteed to be a hit.

Death At The Dive Bar in particular is about a fictitious dive-bar murder.

There are puzzles, paperwork, and lots of clues for you to work through in order to solve the mystery.

Plus, you can play along with up to 5 friends if you like.

For those of you that don’t feel so confident in your detective skills, this board game comes with a hint sheet in case you need a little bit of help.

So no matter your skill level, anyone can enjoy this game with their family or friends.

It will make the perfect gift for a true crime fan who loves to try to work out the crimes themselves.

Buy Now

Cards Against Humanity - Scary Pack

3. Cards Against Humanity – Scary Pack

From $11 USD

  • Rating: 4.8 out of 5
  • Reviews: 132,301
  • Category: Card Game
  • Brand: Cards Against Humanity
  • Players: 4+

A true crime-related card game can be hard to find, but luckily for you, we’ve found the perfect one for you to give to your favorite true crime fan.

Cards Against Humanity is a popular card game in which one player puts down a black card that has a question on it.

Everyone else then puts down a white card with their answer.

The person who placed down the black card chooses the funniest answer and the person that said it gets the point.

You have to have at least 4 players but you can have much more than that, so it’s the perfect party game!

Recently they’ve come out with a slightly different version of this game, the Scary Pack. This is why we’ve included it on our best true crime gifts list.

The booster pack contains creepy questions and answers that would delight any true crime lover.

You’ll also receive one of their three spooky poster designs.

Buy Now

Streaming Service Subscription

4. Streaming Service Subscription

From $4.99/month USD

Popular True Crime Video Streaming Services

  • Netflix – From $9.99/month USD
  • HBO Max – From $9.99/month USD
  • Hulu – From $6.99/month USD
  • YouTube Premium – From $11.99/month USD
  • Discovery Plus – From $4.99/month USD
  • Peacock – From $4.99/month USD
  • Amazon Prime – From $14.99/month USD ( Free 30-day trial )

Popular True Crime Audio Streaming Services

  • Spotify Premium – From $9.99/month USD
  • Audible – From $7.95/month USD
  • SiriusXM – From $22.99/month USD

If there’s one thing that any lover of true crime knows, is that there are many different places that you can take in content related to it.

Podcasts, documentaries, shows, movies, audiobooks, and more are at the fingertips of the public.

The only issue is, sometimes you have to pay for access to these things.

So if your friend or family member doesn’t have their own Netflix, Hulu, YouTube Premium, Spotify Premium, Audible, HBO Max, etc subscription then you could consider buying them one as a gift.

Through these platforms, they’ll have access to tons of new true crime content that they wouldn’t have before.

Not to mention all the other types of content they’d have unlocked in addition to that!

You can even purchase an additional user on some platforms so you can share in the fun.

The Ultimate True Crime Trivia Book

5. The Ultimate True Crime Trivia Book

From $4.99 USD

  • Rating: 4.3 out of 5
  • Reviews: 39
  • Category: Biographies & Memoirs
  • Author: True Crime Seven
  • Pages: 193

If you’ve ever found yourself engrossed by notorious criminals or unsolved mysteries, this trivia book is for you.

“The Ultimate True Crime Trivia Book” is filled to the brim with fascinating facts and disturbing details about famous and lesser-known cases.

It covers serial killers, killer couples, deadly women, cold cases, and everything in between.

With a couple hundred pages to read through, you’re almost guaranteed to read a true crime story you haven’t heard yet.

Multiple authors from the True Crime Seven contributed to this gripping trivia book.

Through in-depth research and fresh insight, they’ve produced the next must-read that would be perfect as a gift for new or seasoned true crime enthusiasts.

Buy Now

Linden Cook - Fingerprint Jewelry

6. Linden Cook – Fingerprint Jewelry

From $275 AUD

Popular Fingerprint Jewelry Pieces

  • Necklace – From $335 AUD
  • Band Ring – From $325 AUD
  • Signet Ring – From $395 AUD
  • Bracelet – From $335 AUD
  • Ring – From $275 AUD
  • Double Impression Ring – From $315 AUD
  • Charm Necklace – From $360 AUD
  • Pendant – From $280 AUD

One thing that interests a lot of true crime fans that never occurs to gift givers is objects that match the aesthetic of the topic.

A true crime book or documentary might be the obvious option, but many fans would be happy with something that signifies their passion in a different way.

That’s why we’re suggesting fingerprint jewelry as a potential option.

Fingerprints are a massive part of most criminal investigations and so it’s an interesting idea to mix them with jewelry.

It’s just out of the box enough to be a big surprise!

You can get various different kinds of jewelry with a fingerprint imprinted on it.

Bracelets, necklaces, and rings are all available. And they come in gorgeous colors of rose gold, yellow gold, and silver.

Plus there are multitudes of designs to choose from, you’re sure to find one that fits your style.

Buy Now

True Crime Cosmetic Bag

7. True Crime Cosmetic Bag

From $9.99 USD

  • Rating: 4.8 out of 5
  • Reviews: 1,552
  • Category: Cosmetic Bag
  • Brand: Blue Q
  • Material: 95% Recycled Plastic

This cute cosmetics bag is the perfect true crime gift for a special someone in your life.

It’s designed to mimic an evidence bag, but with some witty comments included on it.

It’s yet another way to add a true crime aesthetic to your normal look.

Not only is it cute, but it’s also very well made and eco friendly too.

These sturdy little bags are made out of materials recycled from used grain sacks, so you can rest easy knowing that the manufacturing of your gift didn’t harm the environment.

It’s perfect to store away small makeup items or even use it as a pencil case.

So check it out if you’ve got a dedicated true crime fan in your life!

They’ll love it.

Buy Now

The Serial Killer Cookbook

8. The Serial Killer Cookbook

From $19.71 USD

  • Rating: 4.8 out of 5
  • Reviews: 1,145
  • Category: Cookbook
  • Author: Ashley Lecker
  • Pages: 128

This cookbook may just be one of the most unique items you’ve ever given to someone, but as far as true crime gifts go, it might be one of the best.

Written by Ashley Lecker, this book contains far more than just recipes.

The recipes themselves are true crime related, each is the last meal of a famous criminal on death row.

In addition to these recipes, you’ll also be getting surprising true crime facts relating to each person, and there are full-color pictures in the cookbook as well.

Since everyone’s tastes are different, no two last meals in this cookbook are quite the same.

There are breakfasts, lunches, dinners, and desserts.

You’ll find lots of variety. So if you think your loved one would enjoy some new recipes and true crime trivia at the same time, then this cookbook is the perfect gift.

Buy Now

True Crime Pins

9. True Crime Pins

From $9.28 USD

  • Rating: 5 out of 5
  • Reviews: 238
  • Category: Accessories
  • Brand: Punkypins
  • Material: Enamel

Remember how we were talking about aesthetics earlier in the article?

Well, this true crime gift idea is another great one for a fan who wants to show off their love of true crime to the world with true crime pins!

The link below will take you to an Etsy shop that sells various handmade pins and true crime stickers.

The designs include iconic sayings from the hugely popular My Favourite Murder podcast.

These colorful personalized gifts for true crime enthusiasts are perfect if you’re shopping on a budget.

All of the pins are of high quality and are backed by hundreds of positive reviews.

That’s why we’ve included them as one of our top gifts for those who love true crime.

Buy Now

True Crime Dog Harness

10. True Crime Dog Harness

From $23 USD

  • Rating: 5 out of 5
  • Reviews: 560
  • Category: Pet Accessories
  • Brand: The Fat Lab
  • Material: Cotton, Nylon, Plastic, Metal, PVC

Gifts for true crime fans don’t have to be boring.

If they own a dog, this patterned dog harness could be a really good option.

It’s designed with all sorts of cartoons that are true crime related.

This includes yellow tape, a crystal ball that says “the husband did it”, and other small and colorful designs.

It has great reviews and seems to be very well made based on all the glowing reviews it’s gotten so far.

It features adjustable straps and comes in various sizes so that dogs and their owners can enjoy it regardless of size.

This is the perfect way to give your friend or loved one a gift to remember, and the best part is that they’ll get a lot of use out of it as well.

Buy Now

Partner In Crime - Eyeshadow Palette

11. Partner In Crime – Eyeshadow Palette

From $34 USD

  • Rating: 5 out of 5
  • Reviews: 92
  • Category: Makeup
  • Brand: Makeup A Murder
  • Material: 100% Vegan

YouTube channels that discuss true crime stories while doing their makeup are becoming more and more popular, for this reason, true crime and makeup are strangely connected.

That’s why this gift could be so amazing for a true crime fan.

The eyeshadow palette is aptly named “Partner In Crime” and is made by the company Makeup A Murder.

It features four diamond shimmers, two diamond mattes, two satin shimmers, and two soft mattes.

That makes a total of ten different shades. Colors range from purple to pink, and from red to black. It’s truly a stunning palette.

And the company is environmentally conscious as well! Nearly all of their products are 100% cruelty free, recyclable, and vegan!

Buy Now

Leave a Reply